Philosopher Thomas Nagel Slams AI Consciousness Claims
famed philosopher thomas nagel, winner of the $1 million berggruen prize, calls ai consciousness 'just ridiculous' due to lack of physical substrate similar to human nervous system.
thomas nagel, a 89-year-old university professor emeritus at nyu, has made significant contributions to thought on morality, justice, and the mind-body question. he recently won the $1 million berggruen prize for philosophy & culture. nagel argues that the emergence of large language models has not altered his viewpoint on consciousness. he believes that ai systems are 'just ridiculous' to consider conscious because they produce only language, which is not a natural manifestation of consciousness. nagel emphasizes the importance of a physical substrate, like a nervous system, for consciousness to exist. he does not exclude the possibility of life forms with different physical and chemical structures being conscious, but ai systems are not among them.