Gary Marcus to Hinton: AI is just mimicry, not consciousness

gary marcus publicly critiqued geoffrey hinton's recent interview, accusing the ai pioneer of conflating fluent text output with actual consciousness by ignoring the underlying mechanisms of generation. marcus argues that while llms can mimic human conversation effectively—a trait he describes as interactive fiction—they lack the experiential internal states required for sentient awareness. he contrasts this with a recent statement from the pope emphasizing that true comprehension stems from experience rather than text approximation.